Purchasing Silver eagle proof dollars in mint condition should be your goal, since the state of a coin is really important to its worth as a collectible. Any coin which is damaged, marked, scratched, or scuffed will usually suffer a serious reduction in value compared to a coin in finer form. Of course older coins are generally more valuable to collectors, but more than just age can affect the value of a specific coin. The value of a coin depends on many factors besides just how old and how rare it may be. Demand is a key factor in the market value of any collectible coin.