When it comes to small cents, specimens that are in mint condition are typically the most valuable. In almost all cases a coin which appears to be in excellent condition will be significantly more collectable than one which is damaged. Also, be aware that a coin's worth depends on more than just its age. As a general rule, the older and rarer a coin is, the more valuable it will be; but did you know that other situational factors play a role, too?. Coins can be valued by many factors, the most important of which is, of course demand.